These are cute, and I'm spending today working around the house and breaking them in. I'm sure they will stretch to accommodate - the leather is pretty soft - but I am a solid 8.5 with a medium width, and these are tight out of the box. I can only buckle them on the very last hole. Am keeping them and breaking in rather than going through the bother of returning them, but I wish I had ordered a size 9.The ones I ordered came in WAAAAAAYYYY too small. I have found that in some brands when I order blndly online like this a 7-1/2 is too big and I have to send it back. This time the 7-1/2 was so much too small I couldn't even get my foot inside it. Funny because I tried on a size 7 in the brown ones in a store and they were just a little bit too small then too. It looks like I may take an 8 or 8-1/2 in these, so I'm saying they run SMALL. I tried them on in a clearance shoe store which of course never carries ALL sizes in anything, that's why I'd ordered half a size larger than what I tried on, and still too small. Oh well. They seem nice and sturdy.Very comfortable, can be worn as casual or dressy. Looks good with jeans, shorts or sundresses. Leather straps are tight at first but loosen and soften up as you wear. Very well made and good value!Love these! I read the reviews and they said this shoe runs small so I ordered a whole size up from my usual size 9. Yes, they run very small so size 10 fit me perfectly!!!!! Very stylish and they are comfortable as well. Glad I ordered them, I will order the brown ones as well.Seller awesome to deal with. And I love the black pair...I ordered the brownLove these shoes, great price!!